Jul

17

2008

I decided to check out “I Survived a Japanese Game Show,” an ABC send-up featuring Tony Sano and Rome Kanda. Sano, a Japanese-American, plays something of a straight man to Kanda’s exaggerated Johnny Gilbert. It’s standard reality-TV fare—win the games, avoid eliminations, get a big cash prize. The only real twist is some “cultural learning” opportunities thrown in here and there. But the viewing left me with a few questions.

Number one: Is it racist? My quick answer—no. I haven’t watched every episode, but ABC seems to be poking fun at the zany game shows in Japan, not Japanese culture as a whole. Twenty or thirty years ago, that may not have been the case. Have you seen anything on the show that rubbed you the wrong way?

Number two—There are no Asian-Americans competing on this show. What does that say, if anything? Maybe Asian-Americans are just too smart to sign up. But it’s also possible that the producers purposely left Asians out. Non-Asians frequently fail to recognize differences among Eastern cultures, and between actual Asia and Asian-America. There’s an assumption made—“You’re Asian, so you must understand.”

Case in point: I once read about a Korean-American girl waitressing at a Thai restaurant. She was frustrated when customers asked her to “interpret” the meaning of the Thai artwork. When she explained she was not Thai, they countered with, “Oh, but the cultures are very similar.”

This kind of thinking frustrates me as well. I would really like to have seen an ABC (as in, American-born Chinese) or Filipino perspective on the wacky Japanese games.

Three—do you prefer watching actual Japanese game shows? Do the originals translate well?

Below is a link to Tony Sano’s interview for Asian Week:

Asian Week Article


Categories :



16 Comments »

I hate how they can’t be original. They’re so desperate to make money!


Well it’s funny to see Americans do Japanese things. I hope they don’t degrade Japanese culture though.


I don’t think Japan will agree to it if they do.


I want to be on a Japanese game show.


Me too. Are they actually going to show this on tv though?


Well it’s going to air this week on ABC.


I hope so. I want to watch it. smile Better than youtube. Lol.


Cultures are very similar?! Wtf.


It’s really sad how stupid some Americans are.


Yeah, the American assumptions about Asian cultures are something we see all the time. But it really seems that ABC is respecting Japanese culture. Like, some of the activities involve learning about Japanese culture....should be educational for the contestants. Host Tony Sano is actually half Japanese, but really in touch with his Japanese heritage. I saw on the ABC site that the show concept was hatched by a Scandinavian company.


I have no idea why some idiot Whites think that way about Asian cultures.  They’d probably get all uppity too if someone said the same thing, that British, French, German, American, and Italian cultures were all the same.

I bet most don’t even realize just a ridiculously diverse and fragmented and different the country of China is within regions and geographies, to the point where people even have their own languages.  At least in America, northern yankees and southern hicks speak the same language without local dialects.


just = just how


Amen to your 1st comment Al. I’ve peeped at the show and it’s insane. Some stuff they do is so friggin’ gross! Some things they show are funny as well.


I would be fine with the show if they didn’t degrade the Japanese culture.


I love this show!!!
I’d love to compete!!!
I’ve been a loyal japanese game show fan for years,
so I’d have an advantage lol…
And as for the Korean waitress working in Thai restaurant…
If I worked in a Thai restaurant, I’d study to know what I’m serving…

On the subject of “degrading” “racist” issue…
There are definitely some parts that’s questionable in these shows…
Don’t know if you guys have seen MXC on Spike…
They ridicule the contestants and make fun of the MC’s by
dubbing in funny remarks over them…
While in places like NY or CA, or any other states that Asians are heavily populated, people know what real Asian are like…
it bothers me a little of a rare chance that people in mid-west or
places where there aren’t many asians, Americans may think that’s the way asians act… just a little bit…
BTW I love and laugh at MXC LOL…


Ok...firstly...DON’T use the term “Whites”. Last I checked everyone not Asian, Hispanic, or Black was considered White regardless of what nationalities were actually represented or even if the people you are referring to were even 1/4 something else. Don’t try to defend cultures and remark on racial bias then go and use that word. You just look as racially biased and arrogant. Thanks.

Secondly, nothing stops every other culture in the world from poking fun at America. It’s a free world for the most part so enjoy poking fun. We’ll laugh with you. We already are from our beloved (/sarcasm) president.

MXC was hilarious when it started. Dubbed in complete comedic English to poke fun at everyone involved in that Asian game show from the hosts to the contestants it made for good entertainment for a little while. But even that got boring becuase they just keep going with the same jokes. This new show gives Japan a way to poke fun at Americans now by watching us try the same things we were poking fun at in MXC.



Dear Guest, please login to comment

Login with your Ningin account

Create New Account | Forgot password?


OR login with Facebook


Please keep the comments clean by not posting advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks. Terms of Use.

Popular Blog Posts

Archives

Categories

Tag Cloud